Core Values are lame. Here’s something better.


Hey GirdleyWorld!

We’ve all been frustrated with meaningless “core values” inside of companies.

But I’ve seen the solution in action. So today:

  • How behaviors can do what values can’t

Thanks for reading!


BUT FIRST…

I’ve got some newsletter sponsorship slots available!

  • 39K+ subscribers, >50% open rate
  • High-value audience: SMB owners, leaders, investors, and entrepreneurs

These ad slots deliver.

“This has been my only marketing channel for the last year — it’s a 5x return on ad spend.”
- One of our regular sponsors

Let’s get you some leads! Email clayton@girdley.com to get started.


The problem with Core Values

  • Communication
  • Respect
  • Integrity
  • Excellence


Great concepts, but do your eyes glaze over? Mine do.

This could be any business in America.

But guess what? Those “Core Values” belong to Enron.

You know: manipulated financial statements, insider trading, a cutthroat firing policy… even suspending their “code of ethics” so leadership could do shady stuff.

So what happened to “Integrity”?

Here are 3 big problems with core values:

  • They’re not actionable. Of course “integrity” is important. So what?
  • They’re not specific. Is “excellence” working a 60-hour week or getting the job done well?
  • They’re not complete. You can’t proscribe an entire culture with 3-5 buzzwords. Life’s too complicated.

Core Values should help us make hard decisions. But when they’re written like this, they don’t.

Luckily, there’s a better way. It’s called Core Behaviors.

Core Behaviors

A few years ago, a CEO friend of mine named Andrew was frustrated with his company’s values.

So he introduced a set of 18 core behaviors.

Here’s a few of them (I’ll put the whole list at the bottom).

Using “behaviors” fixes the 3 big problems with the classic Core Value approach.

They’re specific. They’re actionable. And with 18 behaviors listed, they’re closer to a complete picture of how the team operates.

They define the specific actions that are special to a culture — which, in turn, defines who we are as an organization.

Choosing behaviors like this is the first step. Then you need to get people to actually live them.

Next: Andrew’s 4-step process to bring Core Behaviors to life.


TOGETHER WITH HOLDCO CONFERENCE 2025

Interested in owning multiple businesses? Want to learn, connect, and scale up your operations?

HoldCo Conference might just be the best weekend of your year.

Learn advanced techniques from owners, operators, and incubators. Meet new people and get inspired. Speakers include:

  • Walker Diebel
  • Reg Zeller
  • Logan Leslie
  • Chris Munn
  • Sieva Kozinsky
  • Me! (Girdley)

Plus enjoy the amazing amenities of Michelin-recognized Sundance Resort — discounted spouse tickets also available!


Putting your Core Behaviors into action

To get people to actually operate with his core behaviors, he used these 4 steps:

Define → Introduce → Reinforce → Revise

Here’s how he did it.

1. Define the Behaviors

Most core values creation has everyone come to a consensus.

Which explains why they’re often worthless!

With Core Behaviors, the CEO writes the first version of them, since they need to embody the behaviors they want for their company.

2. Introduce the Behaviors

Every Monday, Andrew emailed the entire company every Monday morning.

He’d explain one of the Behaviors, and talk about what it meant to him.

And he’d talk about how he was trying to live it personally.

He did this for 18 weeks, until he’d gone through his whole list of behaviors.

This is key: any Behaviors will fail if the leader doesn’t embody them publicly.

3. Reinforce the Behaviors

Once Andrew had written about each behavior, members of the team took turns doing the same thing.

One would write that week’s email to the whole company, saying what that week’s Core Behavior meant to them.

On the 18th week, they repeated the cycle.

4. Revising the Behaviors

Andrew, as CEO, maintains the list of Core Behaviors.

He revises them periodically based on input from everyone.

Sometimes adding, subtracting, and changing.

The behaviors continue to evolve with the company, people, and times.

The results

Replacing Core Values with Core Behaviors has worked wonders for Andrew’s business.

Culture is now driven bottom-up. It has defined a common identity for the company. And teammates don’t tolerate when they see people not living the behaviors.

Hard to beat as an actionable way to define and reinforce company culture.

Just keep in mind: practice what you preach. If the leader doesn’t follow Core Behaviors, why should anyone else?

If you’re interested, click here to see all 18 core behaviors from Andrew’s company.


Thanks to Near for keeping this content free.

Offshoring isn’t about paying less. It’s about getting more.

Most small businesses can’t afford an outbound sales engine, or a team of SDRs to handle warm leads at scale.

But as the workforce goes global, you can suddenly afford three, four, or even five highly talented people for one American salary.

And your business can do more work.

Get a list of pre-vetted candidates, plus a 5% discount on your first hire at hirewithnear.com/girdley.


3 things from this week

  • Appetizer: Did you know I ran a Halloween costume store for a while? It didn’t end well. Got me thinking about the pros and cons of owning a seasonal business.
  • Main: I love a good graphic. Here’s a manager’s guide on what to do with employees, based on their trust vs performance. From Ayman Al-Abdullah’s great thread on hiring.
  • Dessert: Frank Lloyd Wright designed a total of one office building. And it’s for sale. The guys on Real Estate Anonymous broke it down last week — give it a watch!

Have a great week!

Michael

Not subscribed? Sign up here!
Sponsor an issue and reach 39,000+ business readers → email clayton@girdley.com

MORE WAYS I CAN HELP YOUR BUSINESS

💡 Go from idea to profitable business The Low-Risk Business (ebook)
Get the 5-step framework I've used to build multiple businesses from scratch. 40 pages of hands-on, practical guidance.

📈 Group for small business leaders → join Scalepath
Connect, learn, and grow your business with expert guidance, vetted community, detailed playbooks, and other resources. For businesses making $500K+ in revenue.

🌎 Hire incredible talent → talk to Near
Meet your hiring needs with top-tier Latin American talent for 70% less than US staff. My team at Near takes care of all the headaches. Get in touch today.

⛷️ Multiple business owner?HoldCo Conference 2025
The event for HoldCo owners, operators, and executives looking to meet, learn, scale and grow (and ski). Join us at Sundance Resort in Utah, Mar 31-Apr 3 2025.

113 Cherry St #92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2205

Unsubscribe · Preferences

Girdley's Small Business MBA Newsletter

The stuff they don’t teach at school. Learn world-class strategy, operations, and tactics from my 30 years of hard-won small business experience.

Read more from Girdley's Small Business MBA Newsletter
The 11 pieces of advice I keep giving

Hey GirdleyWorld! It’s the end of the year, so I’m looking back on the things that never change. Here’s a classic: 11 things most entrepreneurs need to hear Let’s do it! I love solving problems with people. Whether it’s 1-on-1, in my peer group, or with the CEOs of my companies. One thing I’ve learned: a lot of people make the same mistakes. So I find myself repeating the same pieces of advice. Here are my top 11 pieces of advice for entrepreneurs. How many of these apply to you? — 1. “Your...

10 books that shaped my life

Howdy folks! Want an easy Christmas gift for the business nerd in your life? I’ve got you covered. Because today it’s… 10 books that teach you how the world works (Plus handy Amazon links, so Santa Girdley earns a few cents in affiliate fees!) Most business books these days are 90% filler. They should have been a pamphlet. It’s usually better to just find a podcast where the author’s a guest. But there are exceptions. Here are 10 of them, and each one shaped who I am today. They’re not super...

Underperforming employee

Quick housekeeping note! We're switching newsletter providers, so the next few emails may come from a Beehiiv domain. Keep an eye out for it - and if you have any issues, reach out to media@girdley.com. Hi folks! Every week, I’m sharing a practical, hands-on guide on how to run your small business better. Today: How to deal with an underperforming employee. By the way — if you’ve ever been curious about joining the community and getting access to our whole playbook library, there’s no better...